Advocate. A person who publicly supports, champions and recommends a particular cause.

In the last few months I have increasingly seen and heard that we should be an advocate for PE. Both in the online and the real world space that I exist in. In a recent twilight CPD session we were encouraged to actively promote our subject and the many benefits it offers. I had assumed, perhaps wrongly, that all subject teachers do this on behalf of their subjects. It is right and proper to advocate for our subject, day in and day out.

In a school system with ever decreasing funding, ever increasing focus on examination results and an ever shrinking curriculum we do need to advocate for PE to ensure it doesn’t become a marginalised, unwanted and unloved subject. Since the 2 hour minimum expectation for curriculum PE was removed Key Stage 4 PE time has begun to reduce. Based on the logic that the expectation was creating a ceiling of provision and without it schools would be free to put in as much PE as they want, the opposite has begun to happen. It is a worrying trend and one that needs to be halted and reversed.

So how should we advocate for our subject? Well it appears that our subject is the Superman of all curriculum subjects. There is nothing it can’t do. Improve exam results? Check. Make better British Citizens? Check. Cure obesity? Check. Bring about world peace? Maybe. Perhaps you can sense a touch of cynicism in my words? Let’s take improving exam results as an example. There is no doubting from evidence that is continually being produced on a monthly basis that active, healthy and fit children tend to do better in examinations. However nearly everything we do in schools has a positive effect on achievement. So the real question is ‘how’ much of a positive effect it has?

Physical activity in John Hattie’s effect sizes for student achievement does not rank highly. Neither does Sports Particpation in the EEF Toolkit’s list of interventions, although I am very interested in what evidence the ‘Fit to Study‘ research will find. Advocating our subject on behalf of improving academic achievement is, for me, built on quick sand. The current evidence is far from conclusive, although I do concede there are issues using Hattie’s effect sizes and the EFF Toolkit as our sole arbitrar of evidence. However a clued up Senior Leadership Team could just as easily use this evidence to justify their reduction of PE curriculum time to be replaced with an alternative intervention that could provide a greater impact on results. The only thing we can be sure about with increasing PE time in the curriculum is there is no evidence that it has a negative impact on academic achievement. If we use the improvement of exam results as a means of advocating our subject, are we saying that is what is most important in a child’s education?

I personally feel that with all this advocacy going on for PE, we are having the wrong conversations. There is a growing disconnect of what people want our subject to offer and what it can actually offer. PE isn’t a solution to all of societies ills no matter how much we might think it is. Perhaps I do our subject a disservice but complex problems require solutions that PE just can’t provide. Daily movement, especially outside, has many powerful benefits to bring into a individuals life. The true power of PE as a subject, if it is well delivered, lies in empowering children to access those benefits on their own terms. Education of the physical so they can move. Education through movement so they can deepen their understanding, find meaning and hopefully take responsibility. If this isn’t enough to ensure a strong place in a child’s education and the school curriculum, then perhaps PE shouldn’t be there? However, I feel empowering children to move is a realistic, achievable and deeply profound enough reason for which to be an advocate.

We really need to think carefully about what type of PE we advocate for, because we might just end up with that kind of PE.

8 thoughts on “Advocate

  1. I think it’s a bit bigger than individual advocacy – that message can be misjudged as empire building or base job security. And social media advocacy is only effective if you and you highly organised and influential band of followers have the ear of decision makers online – usually unlikely as many administrators are yet to become online citizens. So that means groups that represent peak bodies (i.e. Physical Education teachers) need to be active in advocacy. Power in the union and all that. Luckily in my setting, our government education departments mandate the amount of PE that needs to be taught (in all education sectors), so it becomes an issue of advocating for quality, rather than existence. I look on with sorrow at the situation in other countries where the decision is left to states, districts or schools as to how much, if any, PE is provided in schools. This calls for action and advocacy on a grand scale, to win back what should be naturally given.Ironically, the amount of PE expected in schools was probably greater in the “old days” when it was less about lifelong skills and more about militaristic drills and training (PT rather than PE). Whilst it would be ill advised to wish for a return to those days in one respect, it could return PE to a more everyday expectation in daily school life. Be careful what you wish for. Good luck.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Brendan, thanks for your comment. I agree with all your points. Our professional bodies in the UK are trying to start a teacher advocacy movement in response to the many changes that have happened to PE over the last few years. They think if they get the backing of teachers behind them then they will have a more powerful voice when they lobby the government. I think my issue is that the message is confused and not based on evidence. In the long run that isn’t going to help PE delivery improve and perhaps might be counterproductive. As individuals all we can do is what is in our control and advocate as best we can in our own personal and professional spaces. For me that is a clear message that good quality PE can empower children to move and access all the benefits movement can bring. I’m happy that message is strong enough.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.